Culture Is Less About What You Promote and More About What You Permit
I saw a Facebook reel the other day that made me laugh out loud.
The caption read: "When the new hire understands why the company was hiring."
Then it cut to Leonardo DiCaprio in Shutter Island, turning to his partner with that classic look and asking, "WTF is going on here?"
I laughed. Then I winced. Because I've watched that exact moment play out in real organizations more times than I can count.
A new leader joins. They're excited. They believed the recruiter, the website, the values on the wall. And within a few weeks, they're looking around going, "Wait... is this really how we operate?"
That gap between what you promote and what you permit? That's your real culture.
Most Leaders Confuse the Conversation About Culture with the Work of Culture
When leadership teams start talking about culture, the conversation almost always drifts to the same places. Definitions. Values statements. Posters. Slide decks. A new tagline. A rollout plan.
All of that has its place. But here's what I've watched happen over and over: the more time leaders spend talking about culture, the less time they spend checking whether it's actually getting done.
The conversation becomes the substitute for the work.
And then a new hire shows up, looks around, and asks the Leonardo DiCaprio question.
The Principle That Changes Everything
Here's the principle I want you to sit with this week:
Leadership culture is less about what you promote and more about what you permit.
When you have a leader who is negative, who drags the team down, who creates a wake of frustration behind every meeting, and that person is allowed to remain in that role unchanged, you have just set the standard.
You can talk all you want about accountability. About high expectations. About being a place where people thrive.
But every other leader on that team is watching. And what they're learning is simple: this is what's acceptable here.
A few of your strongest leaders may push beyond that standard out of sheer character. Most won't. Most will quietly recalibrate to what's tolerated. Because that's what humans do.
The Ones Who Pay the Price Are Your Employees
When your leadership culture is off, it isn't the senior leaders who suffer most. It's the people reporting up to them.
They're the ones absorbing the moodiness. Working around the avoidance. Cleaning up after the bad decisions. Wondering why they keep hearing one thing from the CEO and experiencing something different from their direct manager.
So they start asking the question every employee eventually asks when the gap gets too wide:
Should I stay?
That's when the resumes start going out. Morale drops. Your best people, the ones with the most options, leave first. And suddenly you have a retention problem you can't recruit your way out of.
By the time it shows up on a dashboard, it's been happening for a long time.
Questions Worth Sitting With This Week
Take an honest look at your leadership team:
Who on your leadership team is setting the standard right now, without anyone naming it?
What behavior have you tolerated for so long that it's become part of "how we do things"?
If a new hire spent two weeks shadowing your leadership team, what would they actually learn about your culture—not from the orientation deck, but from what they witnessed?
The Real Work Starts Here
You don't need a new values statement. You need to look honestly at what you've been permitting.
That's where the real culture lives. And that's where the real work starts.
Ready to Close the Gap Between Promotion and Permission?
If you're seeing this pattern across your leadership team and you're not sure how to move from tolerating poor leadership behavior to addressing it, contact me to discuss your situation. Sometimes the hardest part is getting clear on what you've been permitting—and what needs to change.
Want more leadership insights like this?
Join other mission-driven leaders who get Steve's weekly newsletter with practical strategies, real client stories, and the frameworks that actually work, and never miss the latest thinking on leadership transformation.