Your Team Can’t Control the Number (Why Leading Measures Create Real Accountability)
You’ve put the number in front of your team more times than you can count. It’s on the slide, in the email, at the top of every meeting. You’ve explained why it matters and what happens if you miss it.
And it still isn’t moving.
So you say it again, a little louder. Maybe you add a dashboard or tie it to bonuses. The team nods, goes back to work, and next month the number looks about the same.
You can break this cycle, but you need to change the way you think about your goals, and that starts with understanding the difference between lagging measures and leading measures.
When the Goal Keeps Missing
I was working with a leadership cohort at a retail organization recently, and they were living exactly this. Their sales goals weren’t landing.
The people on the floor didn’t see themselves as salespeople. Selling felt pushy, even a little dirty, and it ran against the reason they took the job. The more their leaders talked about the target, the less it seemed to land.
It would be easy to call that a motivation problem. But something sat underneath it.
Their team couldn’t control the number.
Why Lagging Measures Create Anxiety Instead of Accountability
Nobody can make a customer buy. Nobody can make a donor give, a student enroll, or a client follow through.
Revenue, donations, and outcomes are lagging measures. They show up after the work is done, and they’re shaped by forces no one on your team can touch.
When the result is the only thing you measure, you’re asking people to own something they can’t steer. So they try harder, feel worse, and wait to see how the month turns out.
That’s the price of a real strength. Leaders who keep the outcome in front of everyone care about results and refuse to let the mission drift. But a goal with no lever attached doesn’t create accountability.
It creates anxiety.
Making the Shift to Leading Measures
Here’s what changed for that cohort.
They Recast What Selling Meant
First, they recast what selling meant in their world. Their people genuinely believed in what the store offered. If that was true, a customer who left without ever experiencing it had been underserved.
Serving people well meant putting the product in their hands.
They Found the Action That Moves the Number
Then they noticed something: once a customer actually tries something on, they become far more likely to buy.
So they gave their teams a new measure: one hundred percent of customers try something on.
Why This Leading Measure Worked
That’s a leading measure. Here’s why it worked:
The team controls it completely, today, with the customer standing in front of them.
It reliably pushes the lagging number in the right direction.
It felt like service, so people could do it without pretending to be someone they weren’t.
They got more comfortable, and more confident they could hit the goal.
How Leading Measures Change the Manager’s Job
It changed the leaders’ job too.
When you manage only the lagging measure, you find out you’re behind when it’s already too late, and the only coaching left is to try again. Better. Harder. Faster.
When you manage the leading measure, you can see the problem while it’s happening. If someone’s try-on rate is low, you can:
Watch what’s going on
Ask what’s getting in the way
Give specific feedback
Add training
Test a new approach
You’re holding people accountable for something they can actually do.
Watching a number from a spreadsheet is the easy part of a manager’s job. Leading the action underneath it puts them back in the work with their people, and that’s where managers start becoming leaders.
Find the Leading Measure Behind Every Number You Track
So, take an honest look at what your leadership team measures. For every number you track, ask:
Can the people closest to the work actually control this?
If not, what’s the one action they do control that most reliably moves it?
Are your meetings, coaching, and training built around that action, or around the result?
Two Ways to Approach Next Month
From here, your team has two ways to approach next month:
Put the number back on the screen and hope this is the month it moves.
Sit down together, name what your people do every day that the number is quietly recording, and lead that.
The first path is familiar. The second asks more of your managers, and it’s the one that moves the number.
Ready to Lead What Your Team Can Actually Control?
If there’s a number your team keeps missing and you can’t see what’s underneath it, contact me to set up a Discovery Call. In 30 minutes, we’ll work out what your people can actually control and how your managers can start leading it.
Want more leadership insights like this?
Join other mission-driven leaders who get Steve's weekly newsletter with practical strategies, real client stories, and the frameworks that actually work, and never miss the latest thinking on leadership transformation.